Today I found that my esteemed affiliate, the anonymous owner of ScYtH Networks, whom I periodically steal ideas and content from, is one step ahead of me in my quest to bring better technology to my home. (In other words, he wants/needs a new computer too.) Also, he just happens to want the exact same model that I want. How weird is that? Last night, feeling the craving for a new PC (or laptop) even more than ever after six crashes in a six-minute period, I searched all the computer manufacturer websites I could find for the best PC for me. Sadly, everything I saw that was any good had a giant price tag: well over $2,000.
But I won’t lament about the price, because that has already been pre-lamented and needs no more lamenting, at least not from me. Anyway, I looked at these fine manufacturers: Alienware, Apple, Dell, PricePC, ABSPC, Gateway, Sony, VPR Matrix, and eMachines. EMachines offered the lowest price, at $750, but they’re a value-priced PC company anyway (they use cheap Athlon and Celeron processors and offer no extra software or anything). I found the highest prices at Apple, where their new PowerPC G5 would set you back $3,810. (Keep in mind that I customized all the models listed, if possible.)
Before I continue, here’s what I am looking for: (Note, ‘;’ means ‘or’)
Desktop
AMD Athlon XP Processor 3000+; Intel Pentium 4 Processor 3.0GHz 800MHz FSB w/ 512KB Cache & HyperThreading
512MB DDR SDRAM PC-3200 - 2 x 256MB Module
NVIDIA GeForce FX 5600 Ultra 128MB 8x AGP w/DVI & S-Video
160GB Seagate Barracuda 7200.7 Serial ATA 7,200 RPM 8MB Cache
Samsung 52×24x52×16x CD-RW/DVD Combo Drive
Creative Sound Blaster Audigy 2 - 6.1
NVIDIA DualNet Integrated 100Mb Ethernet
3.5″ 1.44 MB Floppy Disk Drive - Black
Microsoft Windows XP Professional
NEC 17″ MultiSync FE771SB Flat CRT - Black
Creative Inspire 6.1 6600 Speakers - Black
Microsoft Internet Keyboard
Microsoft IntelliMouse Explorer 3.0 - USB
Microsoft Wireless Desktop Kit
Laptop
Intel Pentium 4 Processor 3.0GHz 800MHz FSB w/ 512KB Cache
512MB DDR PC-2700 - One SO-DIMM
80GB 4200 RPM ATA100
NVIDIA FX go5600 Module with 128MB DDR
Sound-Blaster Pro Compatible 3D Audio
24×10x24 CD-RW / 8X DVD Combo w/Software
Integrated 10/100Mb Ethernet NIC
Now, this is just a rough idea of what I want; things can be substituted for certain hardware, such as using an ATI video card rather than an NVIDIA. I do not prefer any certain processor manufacturer. Intel is great, but AMD is just as fast and somewhat cheaper. As long as it’s a 2.8-3.0 GHz processor, I don’t care what it is. (Burn Celerons, though!)
I want at least 512 MB of RAM. This might sound like a lot, but my current computer has 384 MB, but it really sucks. The real reason that my computer is obsolete is its mediocre Pentium III 533 MHz processor (equal to about 0.5 GHz), which is why I need a new PC. Upgrading the processor is about as expensive as buying a new computer altogether, and there’s a good chance it won’t work.
As I said, NVIDIA or ATI doesn’t matter. I do want a newer model graphics card, one that supports new DirectX 9 video game technologies. However, I don’t need a 256 MB graphics card, as nice as it sounds; a 128 MB will do fine. Besides, Alienware’s site says that it would cost nearly three hundred dollars to upgrade from a 128 to a 256. I’ll wait a while and upgrade it when they’re cheaper.
I want a 160 GB hard drive, but size doesn’t matter much when you’re talking that amount of space. 160 GB is incredibly roomy; you could store 50,000 3-megabyte MP3s in that amount of space, with room left over for Windows. Really, with hard drives, it’s best to look at three things: price per gigabyte, type of hard drive, and cache/buffer/RPM.
First, you never should pay more than $1 per gigabyte. Sometimes you must, and that’s okay, but you should always know that there is a cheaper drive if you’re paying above the $1/GB threshold. It can be worth getting a smaller drive if it is closer or below the threshold if a larger one is far above it. For example, Alienware has a 160 GB drive for about $200, but its 120 GB drive is only $124. I would buy the 120 GB because it is much more space for your money, even if it’s less total space.
The second thing you need to look at is hard drive type. There are currently two kinds to choose from: Serial ATA and the older ATA-100. Serial ATA, or SATA, is faster (though only marginally) because it can move data from the CPU and the memory to the hard disk and back quicker using a serial cable rather than a parallel cable. ATA-100 is fine for most users, but anyone wanting a small speed boost (in their hard drive performance, not overall performance) should look into SATA technology. Bear in mind that SATA is often times more expensive than its older counterpart.
The final thing you should look at when choosing a hard drive is its cache, or buffer, and its RPM (revolutions per minute, like in a car). Up until lately, most drives had a 512K cache or a 2 MB cache. Now, with 8 MB caches on new drives, this is the way to go. The larger cache allows for greater read-write speed and gives you overall better performance. RPM is the speed at which the drive spins. Never buy a drive with a speed of less than 7,200 RPM. (Except in laptops, where drives are normally 4,000-5,200 RPM. Newer drives may have a speed of 10,000 RPM, but this is only necessary for intense hard drive operations like copying DVDs or video editing.)
The next item I want is an optical drive (CD/DVD). A fast CD burner would run at about 52×24x52x speed, and I can’t bear to wait 20 minutes to burn a CD when I can now do it in five or less. Don’t bother with what the ‘52x’ stuff means, just know that the higher the numbers are, the faster it is. Finally, DVD burners are a new arrival in computer hardware, and they are not yet cheap enough to be worth buying. They can set you back anywhere from $250-$400, and they’re only useful for amateur video editors and the like. You could never fill up an entire 4.7 GB DVD just with backup stuff like documents and installers. Stick with CD burners for now, and just get a DVD reader with about 16x speed for good quality playback.
The next item on my list is a sound card. You don’t actually need a sound card for sound playback, since most computers come preloaded with software drivers for speakers and such, but I would recommend having one for two reasons: a) decreased load on your processor (software sound drivers rely on the processor to do the work, while hardware sound cards do everything themselves), and b) better compliance with other operating systems (if you ever want to switch to Linux, which I’d highly recommend for advanced users, you will need a hardware sound card as Linux doesn’t include as many software sound drivers as Windows does).
Next is the ethernet card. This is a no-brainer for anyone with cable or DSL Internet access, a home or business network, or anyone planning to scrap their ugly, horrible dial-up in favor of something better. These are not expensive and you should never get a PC without one. Speed is not a huge deal unless you need to transfer large chunks of data over your network; otherwise, don’t worry if you get a 100 MB or a gigabit ethernet card.
Floppy disk drives, the next item on my list of tech specs, seems to be useless in the age of CDs and DVDs which can hold so much more data. I would still recommend having a floppy drive for the simple fact that floppy disks are easy and small and sturdy; good for transferring data between home and work or school. They also come in handy when you need to make a Linux or Windows system rescue disk.
Some would wonder if Windows XP Professional is necessary for the regular user. I say that it is because of the extra features it gives you for networking (I will most likely set up a wireless network in my house to share my Internet connection with the family PC). XP Professional also has a better permissions system than XP Home, which allows users to protect their files with higher encryption and security.
For a monitor, notice that I chose a CRT (big clunky thing) instead of an LCD (slim pretty thing). First, I don’t mind the space it takes up. Second, LCD (Liquid Crystal Display) monitors are about twice to three times the price of CRTs. Third, LCDs can be weird with gamma and can display things incorrectly. Fourth, the whole “better for your eyes” argument no longer works because many CRTs now have flat screens just like LCDs. Finally, Windows 2005/6/7 (no date has been set), also known in the beta community as “Longhorn,” will require a monitor with higher DPI than current monitors support, so it isn’t worth it to buy an expensive one just to give it away when I upgrade to Longhorn later.
The final four things are pretty basic: 6.1 Speakers (to use the full power of my 6.1 sound card), mouse, keyboard, and Microsoft “Internet desktop kit,” which is their fancy name for a package of wireless networking tools like a base station and USB NIC (network interface card).
For a laptop, I want about the same thing, just a bit less speed, bytes, etc. because laptops generally have less hard drive capacity and such than desktops.
Another thing, desktop or laptop? I think I want a desktop, just because you get more for your money. A laptop would be nice because of its mobility, and it would be useful in college, but it’s likely I’ll get a new computer for college anyway and leave my dream PC for my parents to use. It’ll be like giving an 80-year-old man a Dodge Viper.
I don’t really want to take the time to post the specs for every computer I customized, so I’ll give ratings and prices for the manufacturers I tried. All PCs listed below are either equal to or above the requirements I set at the beginning of this entry.
Manufacturer - Price - Model - Rating - Comment
Alienware - $2700 - Area51/Aurora Enthusiast - 9/10 - Great, but high price
Apple - $2950 - PowerBook - 5/10 - Anti-Microsoft, but high price and low compatibility
Apple - $3810 - G5 - 4/10 - Fast 64-bit processor, but insane price and low compatibility
Dell - $3159 - Inspiron 8600 - 7/10 - Great, but still quite expensive
PricePC - $1437 - AthlonXP 3000+ - 8/10 - Quite cheap, but not sure if I’d trust a website
ABSPC - $2512 - Athlon64 - 8/10 - One of the few computers with the new Athlon64 processor, price is okay
ABSPC - $2318 - AthlonXP 3000+ - 9/10 - Price is agreeable, like Alienware
Gateway - $2739 - 700X - 7/10 - Pleasantly surprised with bang for buck, but still pricey
Gateway - $1760 - M350X - 6/10 - Good price, but less functionality
Sony - $2876 - Vaio - 5/10 - High end, media-centric, but expensive
VPR Matrix - $1200 - FT5110-PE - 7/10 - Great price, good features, but lower end
VPR Matrix - $2400 - 200A5 - 8/10 - Nice, sleek, laptop, but not feature-packed
eMachines - $750 - T2625 - 8/10 - Good speed, low price, but not top-of-the-line
And thus concludes my research on new PCs and laptops. It’s likely that I’ll end up settling for something much cheaper than this, but I really want a computer that I can be proud of, that I can brag about. Which is why I’m leaning toward an Alienware, just as DJ-ScYtH is.
Note: The average price of these machines is $2395. I have currently saved 2% of that amount.